Old School NY Pizza - Norton Commons Menu

Old School NY Pizza - Norton Commons is a standout gem in Prospect, KY, delivering authentic New York-style pizza with a modern twist. Known for its thin, crispy crust and vibrant sauce, this pizzeria consistently impresses locals like Brent Coleman, who can’t get enough of its flavors. The menu offers a variety of signature pies, including the highly praised Hawaiian and PBR pizzas, celebrated for their unique toppings and balanced taste.

Beyond pizza, the menu shines with delicious sides such as crispy mozzarella sticks and savory wings, adding depth to the dining experience. The stuffed ravioli, praised for its freshness and warmth, complements the Italian-American focus. Friendly, attentive service enhances the lively atmosphere, making Old School NY Pizza a great spot for groups and casual visits alike.

Whether you crave a hearty 18-inch pie or a fresh salad with house dressing, this place delivers quality and comfort, capturing the essence of classic New York pizza while embracing a welcoming Kentucky vibe.