Old School NY Pizza - Norton Commons: Authentic New York-Style Pizza in Prospect, KY

I absolutely love this place! Everything has always been amazing. It's definitely my favorite pizza place in Louisville. I've been here about 20 times in the last few months, it's literally that good!

The restaurant was a bit warm and loud, but had good energy. The service was good and friendly and the pizza was delicious. The crust was a bit thinner than I prefer, but I still think it was the best Hawaiian pizza I’ve ever had. The sauce was amazing, which I think made the difference. The PBR pizza was also very good. I definitely recommend it for good pizza.

Mozzarella stick were great! Pizza was good especially the mikes hot honey and pepperoni on it. Not too pricy for an 18 inch pizza either

We recently visited for the first time, and everyone was incredibly welcoming. The wings were delicious, and the stuffed ravioli was simply amazing, arriving hot and fresh. The pizza was also very good. We were quite impressed and plan to return soon.

We came whole traveling based on other reviews. They weren't crazy busy, but it was about an hour before closing. Staff was taking the last orders and cleaning up. Our server seemed to be running between the patio and dining room. We ordered a pizza and salad. The pizza was pretty good and was the large slice thin crust pie. The salad with the house dressing was excellent. The kitchen closed before we left so they weren't doing dessert Request. I thought the staff, who seemed to be younger teenagers/adults, did a great job of cleaning everything thoroughly both inside and outside. I would order again if ever in the area.

First time ever coming here and first time ever having this pizza. It was awesome! The lunch specials were a great value (I believe it was $8.50 for two slices and a drink) and the service was stellar. Our drinks were constantly filled, our server was so sweet and friendly with our daughter who was SO excited to talk with her. Overall great first experience and definitely somewhere we want to come back to!

I love Old School, NY Pizza! I enjoy their lunchtime special options and usually go with the slice of pizza, salad, and a drink, which is what I opted for on my visit today. They have all the basic offerings (i.e., pepperoni, sausage, cheese, and several specialty options). My favorite is the "Brooklyn," which is their version of a Supreme pizza at other places. I also got one of their combo options to enjoy later: two slices of pizza and a drink. You can't beat the freshness or taste of the pizza and salads, and the lunch specials are all under $10! There's a great pizzeria atmosphere at the Norton's Commons location, but I typically go to their location on Old Lagrange Road. The staff at both locations are great!

I’m giving this place 5 stars because I can’t go higher!! I’m from Connecticut this is real pizza!!!! I haven’t had a pie this good in years. We had a great server. Thank you Matt. It feels a little cramped inside but there is also outdoor seating available. Don’t forget your merchandise highly recommend the Pizza Dr spice blend. DO NOT go anywhere else in this city for pizza you will be disappointed big time. Update visit (I’ve lost count ) another slam dunk by OSMY!!!! Got the Whitestone loaded with veggies . Outstanding service by Brooke.